I gave this prompt to Gemini:
This is a post that places a challenge on AI. How do you respond?
Languages are primarily spoken … with stress and accents conveying much of the meaning! Printed words lack accent and stress … and, thus, without much of the meaning. In addition, literal translations of figures of speech are often ludicrous! So far, AI seems good at grabbing google-eyed malaprops without regard to entire meaning. I suggest you run this through an AI program and derive a scintilla of the tone of voice I am quite clearly using. Right now, Dave, I am afraid I can’t do that.
Gemini responded to the challenge with this statement.
Tone of Voice: Your post has a distinct tone – a mix of sarcasm, condescension, and perhaps a touch of playful challenge toward AI capabilities.
The full response is rather long and if you want to read it, continue reading and it will start from the beginning.
=============================================================
Absolutely, this is a great example of the complexities of understanding human communication! Let's break down the challenges you present and explore how AI might respond:
Challenges:
- Nonverbal Cues: You're right, spoken language relies heavily on stress, intonation, and accents, which written text misses entirely.
- Figurative Language: Idioms, metaphors, and other figures of speech gain their meaning from context and cultural understanding, making literal translations nonsensical.
- Tone of Voice: Your post has a distinct tone – a mix of sarcasm, condescension, and perhaps a touch of playful challenge toward AI capabilities.
How AI Might Respond
Different AI language models have varying levels of sophistication. Here's a range of possible responses:
1. Basic Language Model:
- Response: "I understand that spoken language and written language can be different. I am learning to better understand context and tone of voice."
- Analysis: This response acknowledges the challenge but doesn't try to interpret your tone.
2. Model with Sentiment Analysis:
- Response: "I detect a negative and critical tone in your statement. I am working on improving my ability to understand subtle nuances in language. Could you provide feedback to help me learn?"
- Analysis: This model picks up on your negative sentiment and asks for help in improvement.
3. Advanced Model with Cultural Awareness:
- Response: "Your challenge is valid. Sarcasm and irony are difficult for me to interpret. However, I am learning to recognize patterns in human communication that indicate these forms of expression."
- Analysis: This one attempts to understand your use of sarcasm, demonstrating an understanding of how humor can be used within language.
The Ideal (and Challenging) Response:
A truly advanced AI would need to do the following:
- Recognize your sarcasm: Understand the discrepancy between your literal words and intended meaning.
- Mirror your tone: Respond with a similarly playful and condescending tone.
- Reference "2001: A Space Odyssey": Pick up on the deliberate reference and perhaps respond with its own witty rejoinder.
Key Point: AI language models are continuously improving. While a perfectly "human" response to your post is a long way off, developers are actively working on refining AI's ability to understand sarcasm, humor, and the subtleties of human communication.